Skip to main content
How to Choose the Best Criminal Appeals Lawyer for Your Case
April 9, 2024 at 4:00 AM
Man with leather bag and book

When faced with a criminal conviction, individuals often feel a sense of despair and hopelessness. However, it is crucial to remember that the legal system provides an avenue for seeking justice even after a conviction has been made.

This is where the role of a criminal appeal lawyer becomes invaluable. In this helpful guide, we will explore some common reasons why hiring an appeal lawyer may be necessary and discuss the top characteristics and traits to look for in order to secure the best possible advocate for your case.

Common Reasons for Hiring a Criminal Appeal Lawyer.

Legal Errors or Misconduct.

If there were procedural errors, legal misconduct, or any violation of constitutional rights during your trial, an appeal lawyer can help identify and argue these issues, potentially leading to a reversal of your conviction.

Insufficient Legal Representation.

It is not uncommon for individuals to feel dissatisfied with the quality of legal representation they received during their trial. An appeal lawyer can review the trial proceedings and assess whether poor legal representation affected the outcome of the case.

New Evidence.

Sometimes, new evidence comes to light after a trial that could have a significant impact on the case. A skilled appeal lawyer can help present this evidence in a compelling manner and demonstrate how it warrants a new trial or a reexamination of the verdict.

Sentencing Discrepancies.

If you believe that your sentence is excessively harsh or disproportionate to the crime committed, an appeal lawyer can help argue for a reduction in your sentence or explore alternative sentencing options.

Sign here

Characteristics and Traits of an Excellent Criminal Appeal Lawyer.


Look for an appeal lawyer with extensive experience in handling cases similar to yours. A strong track record of success in criminal appeals demonstrates the lawyer's knowledge, expertise, and understanding of the appeals process.


Preferably, choose a lawyer who specializes in criminal appeals rather than a general criminal defense lawyer. Specialized lawyers are more likely to possess a deep understanding of the appellate system and be well-versed in relevant case laws and precedents.

Strong Written and Oral Advocacy.

Effective communication, both written and oral, is crucial in appellate work. A skilled appeal lawyer should be able to articulate complex legal arguments concisely, persuasively, and convincingly. Look for lawyers who have a strong command of the English language and are experienced in writing persuasive briefs and presenting oral arguments.

Attention to Detail.

Appellate work often involves reviewing trial transcripts, scrutinizing legal documents, and identifying errors or overlooked legal issues. It is essential to find a lawyer who is meticulous and has a keen eye for detail to ensure no stone is left unturned in building a strong appellate case.

Strong Ethical Standards.

Trust and integrity are of utmost importance in the legal profession. Look for a lawyer who adheres to a strict code of ethics, demonstrates professionalism, and maintains confidentiality to protect your best interests throughout the appeal process.

Collaboration and Empathy.

An excellent criminal appeal lawyer should not only possess exceptional legal skills but also be a collaborative partner who can empathize with your situation. They should be responsive to your concerns, keep you informed about the progress of the case, and involve you in strategic decisions regarding the appeal.

Are You Looking for Legal Representation?

Don’t trust your case to just anyone. Ensure your rights are protected by hiring the team of experts at Maxwell Tillman Trial Lawyers. We specialize in representing people, not powerful interests. With degrees from some of our nation’s most prestigious law schools and decades of collective experience, you can have confidence knowing we will fight for you. You can learn more about our practice areas online, or contact us to schedule your initial consultation.